Suffer the little children.......
Last week, I decided to poison my daughter.
It's in the genes, you know. I blame Hawley, my second cousin twice
removed. I just cannot cope with Hortensia any more. She never stops.
She will not sit still. She never does as I ask. She caused trouble on
the aeroplane recently. She won't do her homework, her behaviour is
driving the teachers mad and all her academic results have dropped
off. Of course, she is at a disadvantage. Half her class have extra
time for exams because they are either dyslexic or have tracking
disorders, whatever those are. I thought it was something to do with
tuning the video.
I just don't understand it. When I was a child, if you did not do well
in class, you sat in the back corner with a dunce's cap on. That
seemed to do the trick, but apparently dunce's caps are not PC
anymore.
Something has to be done. I was going to poison her, but Mrs Crippen
found out and put me back on my medication. I thought it was a
relatively modest proposal. I am feeling better now. But what to do
with Hortensia? The teaching assistant says she must have ADHD. Mrs
Crippen says we should take her to the paediatrician and he will to
poison her for us.......
Enough! I will stop ranting.
But what are we doing to our children? Twenty years ago, in our
practice of eighteen thousand patients, we had two children who had
been diagnosed as hyperactive. I remember them well. They could take
my consulting room apart in under five minutes. They were treated by
the child psychiatrists with amphetamine derivatives and were
transformed.
Nowadays, the diagnosis of "hyperactivity" has come of age. It has
indeed become fashionable.
ADHD, or whatever the current acronym is, is no longer just diagnosed
by specialised child psychiatrists. There have been documentaries on
it, and there are web sites, so anyone can make the diagnosis. And
"anyone" does. Parents, teachers, teaching assistants, nurse
specialists, even the school caretaker. Even the health food market
has got into it.
Put ADHD into GOOGLE. You get pages and pages of self-help groups,
drug information, and articles along the lines of "make sure you get
your doctor to make the diagnosis....."
I did an audit. In my practice, we now have not two but thirty-eight
children on Ritalin, Concerta or Strattera. So there has been a
nineteen-fold increase in this condition in twenty years.
Really?
These drugs horrify me. They are widely advertised on the internet, on
sites easily available to parents. Look at those web-sites. Look at
the wonderfully healthy, smiling, good looking children who feature.
Do they look like that becuase they are on medication?
Here are some "diagnostic criteria" (sic) for ADHD:
"A child must have exhibited at least six of the following symptoms
for at least six months to an extent that is unusual for their age and
level of intelligence:
1. Fails to pay close attention to detail or makes careless errors
during work or play.
2. Fails to finish tasks or sustain attention in play activities.
3. Seems not to listen to what is said to him or her.
4. Fails to follow through instructions or to finish homework or
chores (not because of confrontational behaviour or failure to
understand instructions).
5. Disorganised about tasks and activities.
6. Avoids tasks like homework that require sustained mental effort.
7. Loses things necessary for certain tasks or activities, such as
pencils, books or toys.
8. Easily distracted.
9. Forgetful in the course of daily activities.
Who decides what "unusual" means in this context? These days, just
about anyone. I have three children who all exhibit most of the above
criteria, often to a maddening extent. My diagnosis is "teenager".
ADHD does exist, and it is essential that it is treated, and treated
properly. But it is rare. The incidence has not increased
nineteen-fold in twenty years. I have seen perhaps four convincing
cases in that time.
Look at the user-friendly drug "information" sites on the internet. Is
the way that these drugs are advertised to the general public
acceptable? Look at some of the concerns that are expressed.
Can someone please reassure me that there are no commercial interests
at work here?
The diagnoses of ADHD can only be made after a prolonged assessment
over many weeks, and should only be made by a specialised child
psychiatrist. Where I work, and I have no reason to believe that it is
not the same all over the UK, the diagnosis is made and the medication
doled out after a twenty minute assessment by a nurse "specialist".
And, very worryingly, do I detect a class structure to this too?
Middle class children with "homework problems" are more likely to be
labelled as "dyslexic" or as suffering from "tracking disorders" and
get sympathy and psychology. Working class children are more likely to
be labelled as ADHD and get medication.
Medicating children for not tidying their rooms? For not doing
homework? For bad behaviour? For losing pencils? For "being forgetful
in the course of daily activities"?
Have we gone mad?
� Copyright NHS BLOG DOCTOR
Picture from: Min of Christ in Art
� Copyright NHS BLOG DOCTOR
posted by Dr John Crippen at 12:18 PM
Please use BLOGGER COMMENTS
|
|
0 Blogger Comments:
Post a Comment that won't get deleted when NHSblogDoctor removes
Haloscan
Links to this post:
No comments:
Post a Comment